sardar pastel was against the reservation in service

 

  sardar pastel was against the reservation in service

 Sikhs muslimss and ambedkar were demanding reservation. for setting this issue an advisory committee was constituted and sardar patel was made chairman of  this committee the general notion is that ambedkar gave reservation it is totally wrong  ambedkar Was only a member of this committee 

sardar pastel was against the reservation in service

see his speech

27  august  1947 Sardar patel

Then comes representation in the services. The general standard that we have accepted is that ordinarily competitive posts must go by merit and if we are to depart from this, the general administration would suffer immensely. It is well-known that since this departure has been introduced in the matter of services, our administration has suffered considerably. Now that we begin afresh, we must see that where we have to fill some administrative posts of a higher level, these posts have to be filled by competition, i.e. by competitive examination and competitive tests. We have made some concessions in the matter of certain communities. which require a little help.

 

EVEN SARDAR PATEL SAID IN HIGHER POST THEIR SHOUD BE NO RESERVATION  RESERVATION WILL BE GOOD FOR POST OF CHAPRASI AND CLERK ONLY

Sardar patel on 14 october 1949

 

 So far as the Services are concerned, for all major posts or all posts which go by competitive examinations there is no reservation on communal grounds. They go to the Public Service Commission. You are quarrelling or asking for the minor posts-Chaprasis and clerks

Is it the Sikh position now that we have not got enough Sikh Chaprasis and clerks ? Are you going to raise the community in that manner ? If that is so, tell me, and If you leave what you have got for the Scheduled Castes, I shall persuade the Constituent Assembly to give you what you want, but you will repent afterwards

26 MAY 1949 SARDAR PATEL

      Unless you put blood into its veins, even if we quarrel about concessions of reservation, we will get nothing. We have to build up this country on solid foundations. As I told you, I was trembling on the day I was appointed as Chairman of this Committee but I felt proud and today also I feel proud-and I hope the House will feel proud--that we are able to bring about almost unanimity in removing the past blots in our Constitution (hear, hear) and to lay, with the grace of God and with the blessings of the Almighty, the foundations of a true secular democratic State, where everybody has equal chance. Let God give us the wisdom and the courage to do the right thing to all manner of people. (Cheers).


26 may 1949

The Honourable Sardar Vallabhbhai J. Patel (Bombay: General):Sir, when I was first appointed Chairman of the Advisory Committee on Minorities, I really trembling and I took up the jobs with a heavy heart, because I felt the task was immensely difficult, owing to the history of the past so many years of foreign rule.

There was a difference of opinion from some progressive nationalist-minded leaders, such as Dr. Mookherjee who from the beginning opposed any kind of reservation or safeguards. I am sure he will be happy today to find that his ambition is being fulfilled. 

 

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

rajput victory on mugal राजपूतो की मुस्लिमो पर जीत 1

Image
source of this article भारत के सबसे प्रसिद्ध इतिहासकार डॉ राम गोपाल मिश्रा जी ने अपनी किताब indian resistance to muslim invasion में इन सभी युद्ध का वर्णन किया है यह किताब अमेज़न पर और सब जगह उपलब्ध है आप गूगल सर्च करिए मिल जाएगी      अगर  बहन बेटियों की शादी से किसी का राज बच जाता तो  पाकिस्तान अफगानिस्तान बांग्लादेश ईरान इराक सीरिया अफगानिस्तान  तुर्किस्तान जैसे और 50 देशों के भी धर्म और राज बच गए होते  क्योंकि जब क़ासिम ने राजा दाहिर को हराया तो उनकी बेटियों पर भी कब्जा किया राज भी छीन लिया यही हाल यही हाल अलाउद्दिन गजनवी सब ने किया आज अगर हम अभी भी हिन्दू है तो इसका कारण ये है राजपूतों की मुगलों मुस्लिम मुसलमानों पर  जीत 636 सबसे पहला आक्रमण अरबोने समुद्र के रास्ते से मुंबई के नजदीक थाना में किया जिसमें उनकी बुरी तरीके से हार हुई 640 में खलीफा उमर ने समुद्र के  रास्ते से सिंध पर विशाल सेना भेजी लेकिन उनके कमांडर mugraiah को सिंध के ब्राम्हण राजा ने मार डाला खलीफा उमर की भारत के अलावा कही भी हार नहीं हुई थी इस हार से पूरा मुस्लिम जगत सुन्न...
Read more

a dalit lady Shrimati Dakshayani Velayudan ( who opposed ambedkars separate electorate demand and termed is antinational like muslim leage

  28 AUGUST 1947 Shrimati Dakshayani Velayudan (Madras: General) Mr. President I find that for the Motion four Members have given their names and first comes the name of the Honourable Dr. B. R. Ambedkar. I am surprised to find that a Member who came in as result of a joint electorate came forward to move this amendment whereas a member who, was all the while standing, for separate electorates and for the so-called percentage is not to be seen in the House to-day. If there was any sincerity in moving this amendment we could have found the person who headed the list, and I do not know why another member took up that responsibility. There may be some reason behind the scene. ' The Mover of the amendment, Mr. Nagappa, said when they come to, the Assemblies as a result ,of joint electorates they may not be coming With the votes of the community and so they are not entitled to represent the community. If Mr. Nagappa thinks that he has come here as a result of such an election, the wises...
Read more

reservation is not right any govt is free to not give sc st obc or any type of reservation

  Reservation is not a fundamental right says Supreme Court see an article in hindu paper february  11 2020 Reservation as right: on Supreme Court judgment      It is quite understandable that a recent  Supreme Court judgment  , that there is no fundamental right to claim reservation in promotions, has caused some political alarm. The received wisdom in affirmative action jurisprudence is that a series of Constitution amendments and judgments have created a sound legal framework for reservation in public employment, subject to the fulfilment of certain constitutional requirements. And that it has solidified into an entitlement for the backward classes, including the SCs and STs. However, the latest judgment is a reminder that affirmative action programmes allowed in the Constitution flow from “enabling provisions” and are not rights as such. This legal position is not new. Major judgments — these include those by Constitution Benches — note that Articl...
Read more